|
|
Bestway's current annual compliance costs
|
| Legal fees: |
$10,000 |
| Nasdaq listing
fees: |
$15,000 |
| Printing,
mailing and filing costs: |
$25,000 |
| Audit fees: |
$58,500 |
| Other fees: |
$7,000 |
| Total |
$115,500 |
|
Section 404 Fees: |
| Third party
planning, testing & documentation: |
$250,000 |
| Audit fees: |
$190,000 |
| Internal
Personnel: |
$150,000 |
| Total: |
$590,000 |
|
Other Sarbanes-Oxley Compliance Fees: |
| Legal fees: |
$30,000 |
| Audit fees: |
$24,500 |
| Other fees: |
$15,500 |
| Total: |
$70,000 |
| Grand Total: |
$775,500 |
Bestway, the smallest of the 5 publicly held North
American rent to own companies, will save over $770,000 annually by
going private. Although not specified in
yesterday's release, company officials say they have been working behind the
scenes since 2002 on taking Bestway "to the Pink
Sheets."
According to documents filed with the SEC, Bestway spends nearly $800,000 annually
on compliance with the myriad government regulations surrounding public
companies. In addition, the actual cost savings of being a non-reporting private company may
be much greater than the historical out-of-pocket costs. New legislation will
likely increase compliance burdens and company officials say this money is much
better spent opening new stores.
Although rumors of an imminent buyout have persisted for years, and will
doubtless increase with this latest announcement, Bestway officials say those
rumors are unfounded. One said flatly, "We are not for sale." Taking the company
private is one step in preparation for expansion as well as to help focus the company's leadership on its
core business.
Bestway has spent the better part of two years undergoing a culture change. The
company, under CEO David Kraemer (who's
who), has streamlined all aspects of its operation
and moved from a traditional rent to own model that maximizes turn on inventory,
to one that maximizes customer satisfaction by lowering turn and increasing keep
rate. A model that, largely due to the competitive affect of Aaron Rents, is becoming the
way of the rent-to-own future. Even RTO giant Rent A Center is experimenting
with the new model.
Rent a Center has been aggressively testing a reduced pricing
structure in Oklahoma and Georgia (140 stores) since early summer. The test includes
lowering rental rates and terms on the majority of merchandise, both new and
used. Rent a Center hopes to learn if increased volume can "outrun" lower
margins.
Some of the most obvious changes at Bestway are the 'Low Price Guarantee', and
12 month agreements on computers and other popular electronics. The companies
current promotion is a Dell desktop computer at $99/month for 12 months and Big
Screen TVs starting at $99/month for 24 months. Sources at Bestway say the
gain in customers and agreements more than make up for the lower margin. Officials
say customers are happier, more loyal, and less likely to hop to the competition
at every promotion. Store level employees are trained to do "whatever it takes
to compete," and it seems to be working. Bestway has reported eight consecutive
quarters of increased same store revenues.
After being stuck at 69 stores since 2002, Bestway is expected to begin
aggressively opening stores in '05. The target number of openings is unknown.
More information on "Going Private"
As a result of widespread accounting scandals in public companies in recent
years, the government imposed strict guidelines for financial transparency.
While a boon for accounting firms, the new guidelines imposed by the
Sarbanes Oxley Act of
2002 have placed a big financial big burden on public companies. As a
result, many small public companies are taking their firms off the public
exchanges and trading privately. back to top
"Going Private" is when publicly owned stock in a firm is replaced with complete
equity ownership by a private group. The firm is delisted on stock exchanges and
can no longer be purchased in the open markets. Bestway will still be traded in
"Pink Sheets." back to top
"Pink Sheets"
are daily listings printed by National Quotations Bureau on a pink paper
containing market maker quotes for over-the-counter securities not listed on any
major market. They are published for brokers and market makers, not for general
public. Most companies listed on Pink Sheets are very small, are thinly traded,
and have small outstanding volume. Bestway's average volume is 131 shares per
day (for comparison, Rent a Center's avg volume is 811,000 shares per day).
back to top
|
RTO Online is the official channel for Rent-to-Own Industry News and the
only independent source of news for the rent-to-own, rental-purchase,
lease-purchase trade. RTO Online (Rent to Own Online) represents the choice
of the entire RTO Industry for trusted information, as it happens. |
|
Tell us what you think
Rate the article at the top of this page |
|
|
|
|